Cole’s Contract: No ‘Moneyball’ Matter

image from

It seems the Phillies are at a crossroads with Cole Hamels… and we're working on bad puns this slow Monday

This past weekend, Phillies president David Montgomery made it clear that money is not an issue in offering Cole Hamels a more lucrative deal. With spring training at our fingertips, more than a few sports enthusiasts have expressed urgency in keeping the southpaw in red pinstripes for more than one season, even though the risk is minimized with a shorter contract and a wait-and-see approach.

Still, it is difficult to overlook the intangibles when considering the worth of our homegrown All-Star (and former WS MVP). With youth and a relatively clean bill of health on his side, signing Cole long-term is a low-risk proposition, whatever the cost may be. While he does have moments of getting rattled, he's become seemingly much more resilient and mature. Cole's community involvement also gives every indication that he's invested in our city and its people. (Then, there's the whole pretty wife equals high self-confidence thing.)

Admittedly, I've had commitment-phobia in regard to lengthy player contracts, and still have a level of dread when hearing the suggested "five or six years" that is being thrown around, but there is something to be said for being able to perform more effectively knowing there's security with your team. And what if we were employing the stat-nerd – dare I say SABR - method in analyzing Cole's performance and value beyond the intangible generalities we just discussed? With a career 3.39 ERA, 1,091 strikeouts in 1,161 career Major League innings, a 1.14 WHIP, and a better than 3-to-1 K-to-BB ratio, this seems like a no-brainer. Not to mention, he gets on base…

Not to overstate the obvious, but even with Hamels signing a one-year deal this winter, his contract situation will be an ongoing discussion this season, so we might as well get it out in the open. Make it happen, Rube.

Pitchers and catchers are just six days away.


11 Responses

  1. I’ve been saying it for 2 years now, and I’m still only 25% joking.
    RAJ- lock up Cole for 10 years, $200 million. Do it right now. He’s the single most important player for the franchise for the next decade- go ahead and show him that.

  2. I get the feeling Ruben’s playing chicken here, problem is, he’s driving a Honda Civic and Cole’s behind the wheel of a Peterbilt. Bottom line, the longer this goes on without a long term deal for Hamels being ironed out, the harder things inevitably become. Let’s just spare all the needless drama and get this deal done. Now!

  3. He’s not even in his prime yet. Ruben, sign a blank check and hand it over to him. Letting him go would be the biggest mistake the Phillies EVER made. EVER.

  4. I’m not exactly sure what Moneyball has to do with this, other than making a cheap jab at those who recognize the value of SABR. The Phillies are not a “Moneyball” team, nor should they be. But that doesn’t mean they can’t use some of the ideas that are expressed by that philosophy. If they had done so, they wouldn’t have given two ridiculous back-to-back deals to closers and the Ryan Howard deal would not have played out as it did.
    The SABR community recognizes Cole Hamels as one of the top pitchers in baseball. Compensating him for that given his age is not an awful idea, especially considering he came up through our system.

  5. And, Cole has said that he yearns to pitch for the Padres and Dodgers when?? He is so Cali that he doesn’t even live there. I hope he walks in FA with a big fat F U to Philadelphia.

Comments are closed.