Projection Models Don’t Hate Phillies As Much As You Do


As we continue to digest the Phillies’ ugliest loss of the season this morning, let’s take a brief pause from dishing out blame and declaring the season over.

It’s probably in everybody’s best interest to step away from emotionally-driven eye test overreactions based on a disappointing three-game series. That’s how you end up declaring the season dead for a 39-32 team that has withstood multiple injuries to this point. Do the Phillies need to get healthier? Yes. Do they need a starter? Yes. Do they need more consistency from the lineup? Also yes! Do they need to fire everybody? No.

See how this goes? I know, I know. You want blood this morning because the Phillies disgraced your fandom, the city, and the game of baseball yesterday. 

Matt Klentak sucks, analytics suck, Gabe Kapler is ________________.

Pound your fist on the table, call sports radio, send your angry group chat texts. Here’s the thing though–and I know this sounds crazy–you can admit this weekend did, in fact, suck and that the Phillies have problems without shoveling dirt on their grave. Start by checking the math.

Baseball Prospectus currently has the most favorable outlook for the Phillies, giving them a 52.8% chance to reach the postseason and a 29.5% chance to win the NL East. Those numbers, while appreciably lower than Atlanta’s 74.3% playoff and 54.2% division odds, still paint an optimistic picture. FiveThirtyEight’s model isn’t much different. The Phillies have a 51% chance to reach the postseason and a 28% chance to win the division, compared with the Braves’ 74% postseason and 51% division odds.

What do these numbers reveal? Truths. The red-hot Braves hold a slight division lead and are currently the stronger team. As such, they are the more likely team to both win the division and reach the playoffs. On the other hand, that doesn’t mean the Phillies can’t get healthier, address their flaws, and earn a postseason berth for the first time in eight years. Simply put, this favorable outcome is not the mathematical impossibility or disappointing certainty many are making it out to be this morning.

Looking at the numbers may not quite be as cathartic as complaining about everything, but, you know, just something to think about.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

8 Responses

  1. Nothing like another crossing Broad “expert” starting off the week talking down to and waving a finger at the fan base with a generic “imsmarterthanyoubecauseithinkilookatthebigpicture” article

  2. I prefer the “eye” test & they went from 2 games ahead to 2.5 behind in 9 days so right now they are pretty bad… If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck.

  3. 1 starter batting above .300 and a 4 hole hitter who prefers to walk instead of drive the ball. Lets not get started on the starting pitchers or bullpen. On the bright side, they’ll finish in 2nd because the rest of the NL East is putrid

  4. Are we really going to pretend that the wild card game counts as the postseason?

    I’d say I’m about to bookmark this article, but I have a REALLY good feeling that it’ll be referenced for the rest of the season once the “I told you so” articles start pouring in following the all Star break.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *