Gardner Minshew Reportedly Could Start vs. Jets (Plus, Newspaper Gripes)
If you missed it on Saturday night, Derrick Gunn, who was INEXPLICABLY let go by NBC Sports Philadelphia, reported that Jalen Hurts is out for today’s game:
Jalen Hurts is out for tomorrow .. Gardner Minshew is in. Boston Scott will be a game time decision .
— Derrick Gunn (@RealDGunn) December 4, 2021
Then, on Sunday morning, Jeff McLane at the Philadelphia Inquirer offered up this regarding the starting QB position:
Jalen Hurts has been trending toward not playing today vs. the Jets as @RealDGunn reported. He hasn’t taken many 1st team reps as last week progressed, per team sources.#Eagles will give Hurts a chance this morning to see how he feels, but signs point to Gardner Minshew at QB.
— Jeff McLane (@Jeff_McLane) December 5, 2021
Different verbiage there, but more in line with what Adam Schefter reported. Will it be Minshew Mania today in The Meadowlands? We’ll find out soon.
Honestly, I’m more interested in two different tweets. I’m interested in this one first:
The @PhillyInquirer website has NOTHING on reports that Minshew may start today's Eagles game. The story is running on other news sites, blogs, social media, etc. Did my "paper of record" go to bed at 6 pm? Is this because its sports editors live out of state & are out of touch?
— Glen Macnow (@RealGlenMacnow) December 5, 2021
I can answer this question.
The Inquirer doesn’t report on other people’s reports. They don’t do the standard aggregation that you find at CB, Philly Voice, SB Nation, blah blah. I am 99% sure this is the reasoning (but if I’m wrong, the Inquirer folks can let me know onTwitter, the same way that Jim Salisbury’s 15 producers came after me). The Inquirer typically will have one of their own people do their own story or file their own report, and then go off of that. You’re not gonna get a story from Scott Lauber with a headline of “Report: Matt Gelb says the Phillies are gonna go dumpster diving at the trade deadline.”
There’s also this, from Marcus Hayes:
For some reason, this season @phillysport isn’t asking us to pick #NFL games, which I’ve done for the past 25 years. So I called @pdomo & @LesBowen, my old Daily News amigos, and they agreed to offer an #Eagles pick & a best bet every week.
We started Week 2.
Week 13: pic.twitter.com/MVUi5JMEV3— Marcus Hayes (@inkstainedretch) December 5, 2021
Not a controversial thing, but interesting to see a current Inky writer call out his employer on Twitter. So Marcus instead reaches out on his own to a pair of guys who just took buyouts from the same newspaper, and decides to replicate the content offering on social media instead. It’s interesting.
Is it…
Could it be…
are we trending toward…
Newspaper Wars?