Skip to content

Ad Disclosure

Trending

Asking One Important Question of Each Big 5 Basketball Team

Kevin Kinkead

By Kevin Kinkead

Published:

Dec 6, 2025; Philadelphia, PA, USA; General view of game action between the Penn Quakers and the Villanova Wildcats during the first half at Xfinity Mobile Arena. Mandatory Credit:
Bill Streicher-Imagn Images

The college basketball season is underway and we’ve got a mixed bag of Big 5 results through mid-November.

St. Joe’s is the only unbeaten team at 4-0. Villanova is 3-1, Drexel and Temple are 2-2, and La Salle and Penn are 1-3.

There have been a few lopsided throwaway games to start the season, like the Houston and La Salle buy game, for instance, and Penn traveling out to Illinois for a thumping. But we’ve seen enough of each team against even competition to get a feel for what they’ve got in 2026 and 2027, and what they need to do to be successful.

We’re asking one big question for each Big 5 team.


Villanova

Can the Wildcats turn win volume into win quality? Or – better yet, both?

Villanova has double-digit wins against Rider, La Salle, and Holy Cross.

But they blew a late lead in the opener, losing a game they should have won against Notre Dame in Rome, and that seems to be sticking in Main Line craws.

As it should, honestly, because beating smaller teams isn’t the problem. Kevin Willard went 24-9 in his first season, and got the Wildcats back to the NCAA Tournament for the first time since the Jay Wright era, but they largely got in based on win volume, and not quality. If you ask a Nova fan what their best win was last year, they might say Wisconsin on a “neutral” floor that happened to be in a different part of Wisconsin. Seton Hall on the road was a big W. But they went 0-4 against UConn and St. John’s in a Big East that was incredibly top heavy, then crashed out in March Madness to a Utah State team that got thumped by Arizona two days later.

That’s why this week is crucial for Nova. Pitt has been nothing special in the Jeff Capel era, but they’re 4-0 with a win over Butler this season and the Cats have to beat them in Yinzerville. Then they get #18 Michigan in South Philly, a Wolverines team that beat Oakland, Marquette, and William and Mary but lost to UConn.

There’s a lot of hemming and hawing about whether or Villanova can get back to being the program they were under Jay Wright, and these upcoming games will go a long way towards answering the question.

St. Joe’s

Can the Hawks put together a complete performance?

Do you want the good news, or the good news?

The Hawks are 4-0, that’s the good news.

And the other good news is that they haven’t played a complete game yet.

There’s no statistic for “finding a way to win,” but that’s what the Hawks have done so far, surviving an overtime home scare from Lafayette and then beating USF on a neutral floor with only 13 minutes of Jaiden Glover-Toscano. They were down to Penn at halftime and outscored the Quakers by 10 in the second frame, getting 47 points from Khaafiq Myers and freshman BJ Ranson in a game where Glover-Toscano shot just 3-18 from the floor and 1-8 from three.

They haven’t been close to firing on all cylinders, it would seem.

“Last year I thought our defense held us in games,” said Steve Donahue after the Penn win. “I think it can win us games now. I think it has. I think we have more shooting this year. I think Sean Logan’s ability to handle the ball gives you another option. But I think the defense, as good as it is this early, is probably the biggest surprise.”

The Hawks don’t have a difficult non-conference schedule this season, but if they get by Drexel on Friday they could be in line to play Villanova for the Big 5 title. That’s assuming the Wildcats get the job done on North Broad in a few weeks.

Temple

Can the Owls flip the calendar, and reverse the trend?

It was a rough past week for Temple, which got hammered by Richmond at The Palestra before giving up 90 points at home to Charleston in another loss.

Adam Fisher’s team looked like a collection of guys trying to figure out how to play together and carve out an identity on both sides of the floor.

Then they went to Olney on Sunday and got big games from a couple of holdovers in Gavin Griffiths and Derrian Ford, who combined for 39 points on 15-30 shooting. Griffiths put up a 19 and 10 double-double and Ford had a really nice 20/3/4 line in 33 minutes.

It’s still a little early to determine what the Owls have in guys like Jordan Marsh, Cam Scott, Dez White, and Sir Issac Herron, but Baboucarr Njie put together a nice line of 11 points and 4 blocks in the La Salle win. He’s super-bouncy and provides some solid interior defense for a 6’6″ forward.

The thing about Temple under Fisher is that they’ve started reasonably well before falling off in February. You can live with rough November losses if you’re playing your best basketball later in the season. Is this the year they flip the calendar, and improve steadily from start to finish?

La Salle

Can the Explorers limit turnovers?

Nobody would fault La Salle for turning the ball over 19 times at Houston or 13 times at Villanova.

But the Explorers coughed it up 12 times in the Long Island win and were plagued by turnovers in the 84-71 home loss to Temple on Sunday, a game they entered as a -1.5 favorite.

“We had 15 turnovers,” Darris Nichols said after the Temple loss. “That’s too many to win the game. Either throwing it out of bounds or throwing it to the other team, I told the staff, we’re making some turnovers that not even the Washington Generals make. We gotta clean that up in a hurry.”

Rob Dockery led the Explorers with 14 points, but also turned the ball over five times. He had previously been plagued by foul trouble.

“I think the biggest thing for Rob is decision making,” Nichols said. “(Sunday), he didn’t commit the fouls he’s been committing over the last few games, but some of his passes, he’s gotta clean those up. He knows that. You see the frustration on his face when he made those passes. His decision making has got to be a lot better.”

Drexel

Can the Dragons win the close games?

Zach Spiker’s team has been in three straight battles that were decided by 3 points, 2 points, and 2 points, defeating Colgate and and Maine while falling to American at home.

It was a somewhat similar situation last season, when Drexel lost five games by five points or less, and won six games by five points or less. They’ve consistently finished above .500 since the pandemic but have only touched 20 wins once since Spiker turned the corner with this program.

You sense that if they can get some of these toss-up games to go their way, they can break through that 17-18 win ceiling and replicate what they did in 2023-2024.

Penn

Can the Quakers make more plays in clutch situations?

Penn played well in tough losses to Navy and Saint Joe’s, one on a neutral floor and the Big 5 game on the road.

They just didn’t make enough plays down the stretch and fell short to mid-majors from larger conferences. The margins were super-thin with under five minutes to play in both games, with the score being within five points.

Interestingly, it reversed the trend from the Howard game, when they were down 31-25 at halftime and then blew the Bison’s doors off in the second half, going on to win by 13.

The path to March Madness is the same as it was last season for Fran McCaffery’s team. Qualify for the Ivy League tournament and then win those two games to punch your ticket. This is largely the same team that beat Harvard and Yale in overtime in consecutive March thrillers, so you know they’ve got the right personnel for another run. That includes TJ Power, Augustus Gerhart, Michael Zanoni, AJ Levine, and Lucas Leuth. Heck, they won the Ivy tournament without Ethan Roberts, who was the only big departure this offseason. This group has played in some big contests together, and they’re good enough to take one of these next games from La Salle, Drexel, and Towson. They beat the Explorers and Dragons last season and they have the personnel to do it again before conference play begins.

Kevin Kinkead

Kevin has been writing about Philadelphia sports since 2009. He spent seven years in the CBS 3 sports department and started with the Union during the team's 2010 inaugural season. He went to the academic powerhouses of Boyertown High School and West Virginia University. email - k.kinkead@sportradar.com