Skip to content

Ad Disclosure

Penn

Fran McCaffery Says Villanova’s Big 5 Proposal “Was Not Anything That Anybody Would Have Ever Considered Seriously”

Matt Schultz

By Matt Schultz

Published:

Nov 5, 2026; Champaign, Illinois, USA; Penn Quakers head coach Fran McCaffery reacts during the first half against the Illinois Fighting Illini at State Farm Center.
Ron Johnson-Imagn Images

Almost a month removed from Villanova announcing they’d be leaving the Big 5, information and opinion on the matter keeps on trickling out from those familiar with the negotiation, if you can call it that.

Speaking to the media after Penn’s loss to St. Joe’s on Saturday, Fran McCaffery was asked about Kevin Willard and company’s decision to walk away from the Philadelphia college basketball institution, and he offered a refreshingly straightforward assessment of what happened – that Villanova simply didn’t want to be in the Big 5, and their proposal for a new structure wasn’t a real proposal at all:

MCCAFFERY: “I don’t really have any thoughts on it because I haven’t had any conversations about it. You know, I’m a very practical guy. They want to be in the Big 5, they’ll be in the Big 5. You know,you want to do what you want to do, that’s up to them. But I will say the proposal was not a proposal. You know, when a proposal is unanimously declined four seconds after it’s presented, it’s not a proposal. So I don’t have any animosity toward him. I consider Kevin (Willard) a good friend. He’s a good man. He’s a very good coach, I’ve coached against him for years. A lot of respect for Villanova. And they made a decision to do what’s right for their program and I respect that. And I’m not hating on anybody.“

REPORTER: “What do you mean it wasn’t a proposal?”

MCCAFFERY: “The proposal was not anything that anybody would ever, ever considered seriously. And they should have known that before they proposed it. And then they say, well, you know, we made a problem — no you didn’t. That wasn’t a proposal. Nobody was going to do it. Nobody even considered it for more than four seconds.”

To refresh your memory, the proposal the Penn coach is referencing here is the pitch Villanova gave to the rest of the Big 5 for a new in-season framework — one that would essentially give the Wildcats an automatic top seed in the Big 5 tournament.

Here’s the summary from a recent blog:

With the current three-year format coming to an end after this season, Villanova gave the other schools an ultimatum: set up the Big 5 in a bracketed format where the top two seeds get a bye and play the winners of the 3-6 seeded teams in the top seeds’ buildings, or they walk. According to reporting from Owls Daily, quoting Temple A.D. Arthur Johnson, and other outlets, Nova wanted the seeding to be determined by the previous season’s NET rating. Willard mentioned this in last week’s rant, and of course it makes sense for them. Villanova plays in the Big East, which means their NET rating is almost guaranteed to be better than the NET ratings of the rest of the Big 5, even if the Wildcats have a shit team in any particular year.

So basically, Kevin Willard wanted 1) an automatic top seed in the Big 5 bracket 2) to only have to play two Big 5 games per year, and 3) to only ever play those games on his home court. 

From there, after the proposal was shot down and Villanova announced they’d be leaving, Willard was quick to spin the narrative as “Look, we wanted to stay in the Big 5, but the rest of the schools wouldn’t have us.” —

Which was ridiculous from the jump. No one bought it. Even getting Jay Wright to echo the whiny, victim-ass spin on TNT didn’t work.

Everyone saw right through it:

And from where I’m sitting, McCaffery’s comments further prove what actually happened here: Villanova didn’t want to be in the Big 5 anymore, but instead of just saying that, they threw together a bad-faith proposal for a new structure as a PR ploy. They pitched it knowing the other schools would turn it down immediately, and that’s what happened. But by putting a proposal on the table and getting it shot down, they then got to turn around and pretend they did everything they could to stay in the Big 5, that the other schools wouldn’t budge, that they’re as upset as anyone that the teams couldn’t reach an agreement, etc., etc. None of that is true, of course, and hearing it from McCaffery just drives the point home, that Villanova is blaming their departure on five schools, while five schools with corroborating stories are blaming Villanova. Safe to say I’m going to believe the majority here. And as just about everyone in the Big 5 keeps on saying, it’s disappointing.

Matt Schultz

Matt Schultz is a comedy and sports writer from Philadelphia. He’s written extensively for ClickHole, The Onion, and Conan O’Brien’s Team Coco. His work has been featured in Vulture, Deadspin, The A.V. Club, Paste Magazine, and other publications. Much of his sports journalism can be found on college basketball websites that don’t exist anymore (PhilaHoops Heads rise up…) email: M.Schultz@sportradar.com