Ad Disclosure
Mauricio Pochettino Did a Nice Job with the USMNT, but the Stench of that Belgium Loss is Never Going Away
Poch is leaving the USMNT to take the Manchester United job:
Hard to blame him. Manchester United is one of the best jobs in the world. They haven’t been amazing in recent years, but you get that offer and you can’t turn it down. Maybe Poch will make United look more like the team of Wayne Rooney, Paul Scholes, Ryan Giggs, Denis Irwin, and Roy Keane. He’s got a lot of work ahead of him.
He’ll wrap up his USA tenure on Tuesday night with a game against Haiti, which will likely go down in the books as his 23rd win. He has 12 losses and two draws and a 61.11 winning percentage with the national team as of publication.
The thing that sticks out the most about Pochettino’s tenure is the belief he instilled in this group and the style of soccer they were able to play. There wasn’t a lot of juice for the national team towards the end of the Gregg Berhalter era, and Poch provided a badly needed shot in the arm. He came in and had the team play a confident, attacking type of soccer, which was truly a departure from the USMNT of decades past. Whereas those teams relied on group defending and set pieces and old-fashioned American resilience, playing collectively above their talent level, Poch installed an aggressive pressing style that saw the team often play on the front foot. He pushed up the backline and emphasized ball recovery while giving the forward players license to get creative and pick out a pass and really go at other teams directly. It really made you stop and think, “hey we have the talent, we can really play this way.”
That’s probably the takeaway from his tenure, that he changed the mindset and culture of the team and had them playing with refreshing type of certainty.
Unfortunately, he didn’t win anything meaningful. Didn’t win the 2025 Gold Cup. Didn’t get the USA past the World Cup Round of 16. Berhalter’s tenure reached the same World Cup ceiling, which, admittedly, is a tough ceiling to break through, but everything lined up for Pocchetino this past summer. The USMNT had home field advantage in Seattle and lined up against a Belgium team that wasn’t half as good as the Belgium teams of previous years. Then they went out and looked tentative and flat and got their doors blown off 4-1 to bring a wonderful World Cup to a maddening and ridiculous end. It certainly didn’t help that President Trump had to go flapping his gums about the Flo Balogun situation, which was asinine and turned the rest of the world against the USMNT, after the group generated a lot of international praise for the way they performed in the Group Stage.
I wrote this in a July story titled “The Nature of the Belgium Loss Makes the USA World Cup Campaign a Failure” –
In this case, the USMNT failed to advance beyond the Round of 16, which they also failed to do in 2022, 2018 (didn’t even qualify), 2014, 2010, and 2006. So if you weren’t able to do something you’ve been trying to do for more than two decades now, how can it be considered a success? The whole point of the U.S. national team is to finally break that ceiling and qualify for the quarterfinals, to beat a good European team and reach the final eight. They failed to do it again, so the tournament goes into the history books as a failure.
It’s extra disappointing because of the good will they built early. They looked dynamic and exciting in a 4-1 thrashing of Paraguay. They got the job done rather comfortably against an Australian team that sat back in defense. The Turkey game was meaningless, so we don’t even look at that one, but the Bosnia performance was good and they buckled down and showed a lot of mental fortitude after the Balogun red card. They drew a lot of praise internationally for their performances and got a lot of people here at home interested as well.
How much blame Poch deserves for that game is debatable. There’s a lot of it to go around, from the players to the coaches to the politicians and everybody else. He had a lot going against him with the way the Balogun saga played out. I can’t imagine trying to prepare your team for the biggest game of their lives while that pathetic circus is taking place around them. Fair or unfair, he’ll enter the history books as the manager of the team that got throttled on home turf in humiliating fashion.
Regardless, the first handful of World Cup games provided some of the most fun we’ve had with the USMNT in a long time. Hopefully the next manager can come in and build on the positive things Poch did, none bigger than convincing this group that they don’t have to sit back and hang on for dear life. They have the talent and the mentality to evolve and play a high-level attacking game.
Kevin has been writing about Philadelphia sports since 2009. He spent seven years in the CBS 3 sports department and started with the Union during the team's 2010 inaugural season. He went to the academic powerhouses of Boyertown High School and West Virginia University. email - k.kinkead@sportradar.com