Skip to content

Ad Disclosure

Flyers

Seems Obvious Now that the Flyers Bungled the Cutter Gauthier Situation, While Cutter and His Agent are Also Humongous Crybabies

Kevin Kinkead

By Kevin Kinkead

Published:

Nov 17, 2026; St. Louis, Missouri, USA; Anaheim Ducks left wing Cutter Gauthier (61) is congratulated by teammates after scoring against the St. Louis Blues during the second period at Enterprise Center. Mandatory Credit:
Jeff Curry-Imagn Images

Quitter Gauthier is on a generational run at the current moment:

He’s on a 10-game goal streak and has scored 19 in that time frame. William “Quitter” Gauthier.

It feels like we’ve litigated this thing a million times already, and it may be at the point where we’re beating a dead horse. The poor animal has been dead for so long that it has completely decayed and the only thing left is equine dust and bones.

But this week Elliotte Friedman was on the Toronto-based Sportsnet 590 and rehashed the whole saga, which added some more color:

Friedman:

“If you’ll remember, Gauthier was leaving school. He wanted to turn pro. And they just brought in Daniel Briere. They changed. And Chuck Fletcher, he was the previous GM. And Fletcher had said, “Yeah, we’re going to bring you in. You know, we’ll bring you in at the end of the season after your college year, and you’ll burn and you’ll play your contract. You’ll, you’ll burn a year and, you know, you’ll play for us.” And, you know, all of a sudden Fletcher was gone. Briere was in. And the one thing I heard about Philly at the time is they tried to say that was a really awful year in Philly. And they tried to say to him, “You know, this is not a good environment for you, that, you know, we have a really bad situation right now and we don’t want to bring you into this.” And what they offered to do was they offered to have them play in the American Hockey League on an AHL tryout. Sometimes teams do that. And, Gauthier felt that he and his camp felt that there was a promise made and promise broken. And that’s, that’s kind of where it all started. And that’s eventually why he ended up being traded.”

We might have a “more than one thing can be true” situation here, because Danny Briere let a generational talent get away, but Gauthier and his camp were also being dickheads at the same time, were they not? This shutting down of communication, not answering the phone, the reported refusal to talk to John LeClair and Patrick Sharp, etc. It feels, in hindsight, like such an unnecessary escalation when everybody could have sat down like grown adults and talked it over and tried to solve the disagreement.

Am I wrong in that thought? There was an obvious path to rapprochement and only one side was willing to walk it.

RE: Friedman’s comments, Briere was in the organization at the same time as Chuck Fletcher, but with a different role. This was largely still a transitional period and the Dan Hilferty/Jonesy/Briere triad had not yet been established. We had yet to enter the New Era of Orange, which makes it somewhat corny that Cutter’s camp went from 0 to 100 just like that, like they were so aggrieved and disrespected by this purported broken promise that their response was to block out the Flyers entirely and refuse to even engage. Justified or not, the fact of the matter is that Cutter and his camp forced their way out. They took their hockey puck and went home.

Now, in 2026, it feels accurate to say that the Flyers did a bungle job with a generational goal scorer and the generational goal scorer is a big crybaby at the same time. He himself has refused to elaborate on the situation and typically bullshits his way through it whenever the question comes up. It seems like a common theme there, the unwillingness to communicate.

Not sure if that’s reassuring for anybody, the thought that Cutter might be a prick in addition to an incredible hockey player. The recent contract negotiation with Anaheim wasn’t exactly the smoothest process of all time, was it?

By the way, the Ducks exited the playoffs in the same round as the Flyers last season. They have 23 points in 22 games and quite possibly the worst defense + goaltending combination in the NHL. They score a ton of goals but give up a ton of goals. They have actually lost three of their last four while Cutter goes on this insane run. The only way they’re lifting the Cup right now is by winning every game 5 to 4.

Of course, the trade brought Jamie Drysdale to Philly while opening the door for Trevor Zegras to follow. Neither of those guys is Gauthier, but it’s not like Cutter walked and the Flyers were standing there holding an empty bag. The Gauthier thing just looks extra dumb now in the light of the Michkov saga, i.e. the “here we go again” thing with a young goal scorer in a not-completely-ideal situation.

If none of this eases your mind, consider the following rhetorical question:

Do you think Gauthier would be scoring a bazillion goals for the Flyers?

Probably not. Rick Tocchet would have him dumping and chasing and mucking and grinding on the third line.

Yes… this is the narrative…

Kevin Kinkead

Kevin has been writing about Philadelphia sports since 2009. He spent seven years in the CBS 3 sports department and started with the Union during the team's 2010 inaugural season. He went to the academic powerhouses of Boyertown High School and West Virginia University. email - k.kinkead@sportradar.com