Ad Disclosure
Addressing the Accusation that Crossing Broad Has an Agenda Against Your Big 5 Team
I’d like to address this tweet:

This isn’t strictly a Villanova thing, nor is it a strawman. We’ve been getting DMs and emails from Temple and St. Joe’s fans nitpicking coverage, saying we are pro-Nova and not giving enough love to the Hawks, or that we shit on the Owls constantly and love St. Joe’s instead. It’s weird. It’s kind of like everybody thinking that Joe Buck hates their football or baseball team. We have SJU people claiming we have an agenda against the Hawks, then the Temple people say we love Nova and the Nova people say we love Temple.
Is it surprising when you think about it? Probably not. You have six different schools with six different fan bases who love their team and hate the other five. The dynamic is one of fracturing and in makes for some legitimate questions in how to blog about it.
Let me share my response to @Philly2Hoboken:

Nova is going to be covered differently than the other Big 5 programs because Nova is the biggest and most successful of those programs. Nova spends more money, plays in a power conference, and has higher expectations. When the story coming into the season is “can they beat the better teams this year?”, and they lose right out of the gates to Notre Dame and Pitt, the sentiment will be justifiably negative. Nobody is going to laud their victories over La Salle, Rider, and Holy Cross because Nova is expected to beat those teams.
As far as the Wildcats leaving the Big 5, it’s created this sidebar narrative of general animosity. Maybe it’s added some juice to the games this season. We’ll see. If you ask neutral people around here, consensus seems to be that Nova has the right to do what’s best for Nova, but it’s also a bummer that classic rivalries like the Holy War are going to come to a halt. “More than one thing can be true.” These people also seem to find Kevin Willard to be a bit of a knob compared to Jay Wright, who ran a classy program on the Main Line and was widely respected.
Now, RE: Temple and St. Joe’s, both programs have underachieved relative to expectations over the past 10 years, but the Hawks have been better recently. They have some upside. They have some solid pieces there. They’re 5-0 but they also haven’t played a difficult non-conference schedule and so there should be nice things written about SJU without necessarily heaping too much praise on big wins over Wagner, Lafayette, Longwood, Penn down two starters, etc. They’ve been good but they also haven’t played the better teams on their schedule.
The coverage should shift for Temple and SJU based on lower expectations compared to Nova, but higher expectations than the remaining three, and La Salle, Penn, and Drexel are what they are. They’re smaller schools in smaller conferences.
For the Dragons, you’re hoping they can break the 20-win ceiling and do better in the conference tournament, which has been disappointing for Zach Spiker’s recent teams.
For Penn, you’re hoping they can replicate last year’s Ivy League success with the entire core returning, minus Ethan Roberts.
And for La Salle, you’re hoping the Explorers can crest .500 for the first time since 2015 and be competitive in the Atlantic 10, which they have not been since Dr. John was in charge.
One thing that often happens is that people say “Crossing Broad thinks this, or Crossing Broad thinks that,” but Crossing Broad is not a monolith. Nor is it a hive mind, with the queen blogger sending out blogger drones to echo a singular sentiment.
We have different authors with different backgrounds and different opinions, which looks like this going back to the site’s 2009 founding:
- Kyle Scott (the Maestro): went to Villanova and foisted Jay Wright and the Wildcats upon us for 11 years before selling the website
- Kinker: went to West Virginia, neutral in Big 5 matters but now somewhat biased towards La Salle because of shared 2005 Sociology classes with fellow alumnus Darris Nichols
- Matt Schultz: St. Joe’s alum, Hawk shill, anti-Nova
- Tim Reilly: went to Penn but doesn’t write Big 5 stuff for us anyway
- Sean Barnard: Sean went to Alvernia / doesn’t write about Big 5
- Luke Arcaini: Luke went to Rowan / only writes Phillies for us
- Nick Piccone: Nick went to Neumann and either works/worked with the Villanova Sports Radio Network, but doesn’t have some overt bias one way or another
- Kyle Pagan: went to Temple, unabashed Owl homer and anti-Nova
- Jim Adair: Jim went to Kutztown and had no Big 5 biases
- Anthony San Francisco: ASF went to both American University and St. Joe’s but he never wrote hoops for us
As far as I know, that’s the list. The site founder went to Nova and is Nova’s biggest ass kisser, but Maestro last blogged almost eight years ago. We’ve had Temple, St. Joe’s, and Penn guys involved with the site but I don’t think we’ve ever had a Drexel Dragon or La Salle Explorer.
Anyway, I don’t think we have any glaring agenda against any specific Big 5 programs. We’d like every team to win, obviously. And if they don’t, usually there is equal opportunity ripping, though it depends on the current staffing, like going from a Nova guy to a Temple guy to now a St. Joe’s guy. But we’ve also published more than 43,000 blogs in 17 years so we usually get everything up on the site at some point.
Kevin has been writing about Philadelphia sports since 2009. He spent seven years in the CBS 3 sports department and started with the Union during the team's 2010 inaugural season. He went to the academic powerhouses of Boyertown High School and West Virginia University. email - k.kinkead@sportradar.com