When Kyle’s away, let all the juicy gossip come out: According to Radar Online (via Life&Style), whose reputation falls somewhere around Star Magazine levels, Aaron Murray and Kacie McDonnell’s engagement fell apart because Aaron hooked up with his brother’s fiancée. Using Kacie’s GRANDMA as a source, Radar quoted her as saying, “[Aaron] knows what he did and he has to live with it.”

It all went down, supposedly, like this: As L&S puts it, former Bachelorette star Andi Dorfman, who was engaged to Aaron’s brother and Bachelorette contestant Josh, “is rumored to have hooked up with Josh’s brother and Kansas City Chiefs quarterback, Aaron Murray, while the couple were still engaged! And not only that, but Aaron was engaged, too, to a woman named Kacie McDonnell. Like Andi and Josh, they have broken up.” Shit, I wouldn’t have given that ring back either.

If this is true, and it’s a big IF, the sudden engagement break-off and quick move-on by Kacie makes sense. But don’t worry, she’s doing alright.

[h/t reader Chris]